All comparisons
PileCalc vs Ensoft SHAFT

FHWA drilled-shaft design — axial and lateral, one browser tab.

The same FHWA-IF-99-025 methods SHAFT implements — α and β side resistance, rock sockets, belled bases — plus the lateral p-y run SHAFT can't do, in your browser. Free to try, $39.99/month for Pro.

SHAFT and PileCalc implement the same FHWA drilled-shaft methods. The difference is the workflow and the cadence: SHAFT is a Windows/USB-key license last versioned in 2023, sized axially only — the lateral run needs LPILE. PileCalc does the axial and lateral design of the same shaft in one browser session.

Platform
Windows desktop (USB key / network license)
Pricing
≈ $950 perpetual + $143/yr maintenance
Scope
Axial capacity & settlement of drilled shafts

What Ensoft SHAFT does well

  • Faithful implementation of the FHWA drilled-shaft canon (O'Neill & Reese, GEC-10)
  • Rock, IGM, gravel and decomposed-rock side resistance plus belled (underreamed) shafts
  • Multi-diameter comparison runs for rapid sizing studies

Where PileCalc is different

  • The same FHWA-IF-99-025 α / β / rock-socket methods, in your browser
  • Lateral response of the same shaft in the same tool — SHAFT needs a separate LPILE license
  • Belled-base uplift, exclusion zones and every intermediate value visible
  • Free tier and $39.99/month, on any OS

The numbers, published

PileCalc's engine is checked term-by-term against the reference codes. A representative sample of the benchmarks — every intermediate value is visible in the app so you can reproduce them yourself.

Free-head pile (EI 1.43×10⁶, D 1 m, L 24.4 m)Liang et al. (2014) exact solution / RSPile
Max moment
792.2 kN·m
792.1 kN·m (exact)
within 0.1%
Fixed-head pile (EI 1.43×10⁶, D 1 m, L 24.4 m)Liang et al. (2014) exact solution / RSPile
Head moment
−581.1 kN·m
−581.0 kN·m (exact)
within 0.1%
Cantilever pile (EI 320, D 0.1 m, L 5.25 m)Liang et al. (2014) exact solution / RSPile
Head deflection
8.75 mm
8.750 mm (exact)
within 0.1%
Cantilever pile (EI 320, D 0.1 m, L 5.25 m)Liang et al. (2014) exact solution / RSPile
Max moment
2.335 kN·m
2.334 kN·m (exact)
within 0.1%
Circular pile, API sand (D 0.5 m, L 10 m, H 100 kN)RSPile verification manual
Deflection & moment profile
RSPile 2018 problems #1/#2/#8/#15
chart-reading tolerance
within 1–3%
Steel pile, multi-layer slope stabilization (17 m)RSPile / TZPile / LPile
Lateral resistance
607 kN
582 kN
within ~4%
Read how we validate — and why against two independent codes

PileCalc vs SHAFT: common questions

Run the comparison yourself

Open the same pile in PileCalc and see the result in your browser in under a minute.

Launch the app